Dr. Joyce Brothers, AKA, Ms. In-Her-Own-World!

Okay, so I’m reading through the local paper, the Scottsbluff Star-Herald, when I come across the wonderful advice column of Dr. Joyce Brothers.  Now, I’m a few days behind on reading the newspaper because… well, I just am.  So this is actually the paper from January 29th of this year.  I usually read Dr. Brothers’ column, think to myself how silly her advice is, and go on my merry way.  Her column in this particular paper, however, just seemed to rub me the wrong way.

The question to Dr. Brothers is from a high-school senior who wants to get a job.  The kid refers to herself (or himself) as P.A.  P.A.’s  dad does not want P.A. to get a job.  The reasoning P.A. gives is, “I am planning on working at a beauty salon after I graduate, and my dad says that is soon enough to join the ‘rat race.’  His only reason seems to be that he wants me to have fun while I can.  Is this normal?”

Dr. Brothers gives a response and answer to the question, part of which is as follows:

“It may be normal for your dad, because he’s operating from his unique worldview and trying hard to keep within that comfort zone that he has set up for himself.  Without knowing more about him, I can only guess that he has had to struggle in his life, and that he views work as something that isn’t very pleasant, just a means to an end.  He sounds like a conscientious guy who has sacrificed for his family.  He can’t imagine you being all grown up and wanting to take on the responsibilities of a job just yet.  He’s definitely got some issues.”

Seriously… what the crap… huh?  I guess all of this seems to make sense… until you get to that last sentence.  “He’s definitely got some issues.”  Is that a typo?  Was that supposed to be “He’s definitely got a point”?  I don’t think it was.  I think Dr. Joyce is casting judgement on this father because of his view of “work”.  Do most people in our society not at least somewhat share the worldview of this father?  After all, it’s called “work”, not “playtime in LaLa Land”.

I don’t think most people wake up every morning and think to themselves, “Ah, another wonderful day of work!”  Maybe I’m wrong, but I don’t think I am.  I really believe that most people view work as a means to an end… hopefully it has something to do with retirement.  This doesn’t mean that everyone absolutely hates their jobs; but given the choice, I think most people could find something more enjoyable to do with their time than work a job.  Dr. Brothers apparently does not fall into the category of “most people”.

I understand that there are people out there who absolutely love what they do for a living.  Those people are few and far between.  I think most of us can remember back to the days before we had to work a job.  Those were, for the most part, less stressful and more enjoyable than time spent in the work-a-day world.  Why would the father, remembering back to his pre-work days and wanting his child to enjoy those days in the child’s life, have “issues”?  What a judgmental opinion to express!  How dare she!

Dr. Brothers needs to wake up and smell the we-don’t-all-get-to-make-a-living-handing-out-our-opinions-as-advice-coffee.  There are those of us who have slight trepidation at the thought of how our children will be forced to change when they enter the work-a-day world.  It’s not about not wanting our children to grow up.  It’s all about how so many of us become cynical, bitter old farts because of the crap we are forced to deal with in life, a large portion of which comes from dealing with “work”, and we don’t want our children to go through what we have gone through.

That’s not an “issue”.  That is a point… and a damn good one.

Besides, the kid is planning on a career at a beauty salon.  You can’t tell me that working with other people’s stinky heads all day is going to be pleasant?  This father is really just trying to look out for the kid 🙂

4 thoughts on “Dr. Joyce Brothers, AKA, Ms. In-Her-Own-World!”

  1. Well said. I was following along Dr’s answer fairly easily untiul the last sentence as well. Wow.

  2. Okay. She was wrong for the issues comment. Way wrong. I hope my girls get a part time job during their freshman year and stick with it through school. I did, and I like to think it helped me get started toward a good work ethic early on. However, if I had the choice financially, I would love to let them go all through High school and College without having to work, but I just dont see that being an option. I remember my part time job thoughout high school, and it really wasnt that bad. I think when work really starts to suck is when you get to the full time five days plus a week, start to make actuall money, then get your self in debt, therefore having to keep the stinking job to pay the bills. A parttime high school job really isnt nearly as stressful(actually can be kind of fun if your working with other classmates) as the realworld job that soon follows.

  3. Steph… yeah, that last sentence seemed so out of place. Guess we don’t share the same “worldview” as the good Dr.

    Lee, I can see where you are coming from. I believe you have a very strong work ethic. I believe you can pass that along to your children. Do you really believe that having a strong work ethic has made work more enjoyable for you? You and I both know this is exactly the opposite from the way the real world works. The stronger your work ethic, the more responsibility you feel and ownership you take in your job… which leads to more stress and frustration on the job. We end up pulling out our hair because we feel responsible for the success of the business we work for, we expect everyone around us to feel the same, and often, they could care less. When the work shift is over, we go home worrying about everything we didn’t accomplish… they go home and forget all about work. Who do you think enjoys work more? Who do you think enjoys life more? There are arguments against a strong work ethic. Welcome to the new America.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.